NOMADEReal Estate

$1,595,000

Active

21-1 Haywagon Drive

Old Lyme, Connecticut, 06371 · New London County

4

Beds

4

Baths

3,766

Sq Ft

2002

Built

MLS # 24186651

Price / Sq Ft

$424

Property Type

Single Family For Sale

Lot Size

1.34

Class

Property

About This Property

In the sought-after Beach Farms neighborhood, this updated 4-bed Colonial feels like a year-round vacation home. The current owners thoughtfully remodeled the living spaces to include a cozy New England stone gas fireplace in the kitchen, a glass walled "at home" gym and a spa inspired primary bath with footed cast iron soaking tub, to mention just a few of these gorgeous additions. The home features a stunning renovated kitchen with custom cabinetry, marble countertops, and a large island. The views and the abundant natural light streaming through the expansive windows highlight the quality finishes and add to the inviting layout that flows seamlessly into the main living spaces. Warm hardwood floors and the two-story great room, create an atmosphere of comfort and elegance throughout. The 1st level primary suite features luxurious details from the bath with heated marble floor tiles, glass walled tile shower to an outfitted walk-in closet. Also on the 1st floor, a formal dining room, office, and a custom designed laundry. Up a soaring staircase to 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a loft area with balcony to check out the view of The Sound. The finished lower level is what sets this home apart. Wood plank flooring, media room, glass-walled home gym, and outfitted wood bar with Chicago Bar Rail to add fun to any gathering. A beautiful deck runs the length of the back of the home with a hot tub, awning and gathering areas to enjoy the breathtaking views. Welcome home and enjoy.

Property Details

21-1 Haywagon Drive, Old Lyme Connecticut 06371 — Single Family For Sale listed at $1,595,000.

At a Glance

4

Bedrooms

4

Bathrooms

3,766

Sq Ft

1.34

Lot Size

--

Garage

2002

Year Built

The Details

Property TypeSingle Family For Sale
NeighborhoodNew London
Address21-1 Haywagon Drive
MLS Number24186651
Year Built2002
Square Footage3,766
Lot Size1.34
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms4
Water SourcePublic Water Connected

Property Details

Other Details

Appliances IncludedGas Cooktop,Wall Oven,Convection Oven,Microwave,Range Hood,Refrigerator,Dishwasher,Washer,Dryer
Association Fee IncludesGrounds Maintenance,Trash Pickup,Snow Removal,Road Maintenance
Colorgrey
Encumbrances RestrictionsDeed Restrictions
Parcel Number2147138
Radon Mitigation Air YNUYes
Rooms AdditionalExercise Room,Laundry Room,Mud Room
Virtual Showing YN1
Virtual Tourhttps://players.brightcove.net/6415895565001/default_default/index.html?videoId=6399925048112
ZoningRU40

Financial

Assessed Value666200
HOAFee Amount1582
HOAFee FrequencyAnnually
Home Owners Assocation1
Mil Rate Total16.23
Property Tax10812
Tax YearJuly 2025-June 2026

Property Features

Attic DescriptionUnfinished,Pull-Down Stairs
Attic YN1
Basement DescriptionFull,Partially Finished
Cooling SystemCentral Air
Energy FeaturesGenerator,Programmable Thermostat,Thermopane Windows
Exterior FeaturesShed,Deck,Gutters,Garden Area,Hot Tub,French Doors
Exterior SidingHardie Board
Fireplaces Total2
Foundation TypeConcrete
Fuel Tank LocationIn Ground
Garage ParkingAttached Garage
Garages Number3
Heat Fuel TypePropane
Heat TypeHot Air,Zoned
Home AutomationSecurity System,Thermostat(s)
Hot Water DescriptionPropane,80 Gallon Tank
Interior FeaturesAuto Garage Door Opener,Cable - Available,Security System
Laundry Room InfoMain Level
Laundry Room LocationMain level, combo Laundry/Pantry room
Roof InformationAsphalt Shingle

All Photos (46)

MARKET CONTEXTOld Lyme
Town Median+198% vs list
$535,000
Old Lyme, CT
Mill Rate
21.45
New London County
NYC Commute
140 min
Metro-North express
Schools
A-
1 graded
LOADING COMP CLOUD…

This listing is +198% vs the Old Lyme median. Verify against same-school-district comps before competing offers.

Contact Allyson Cotton

Fill out the form below and we will respond promptly.

Affordability Calculator

$1,595,000

Down Payment$319,000
Loan Amount$1,276,000
Principal & Interest$8,065/mo
Property Tax$1,595/mo
Insurance$100/mo
Est. Monthly$9,760/mo

Listing Agent

A

Allyson Cotton

William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l

Quick Facts

StatusActive
TypeSingle Family For Sale
ClassProperty
MLS #24186651
Last Updated2026-07-01

Virtual Tour

Walk through 21-1 Haywagon Drive

Open Virtual Tour