NOMADEReal Estate

$2,400,000

Active

38-1 Buttonball Road

Old Lyme, Connecticut, 06371 · New London County

4

Beds

4

Baths

4,230

Sq Ft

1983

Built

MLS # 24180149

Price / Sq Ft

$567

Property Type

Single Family For Sale

Lot Size

5.36

Class

Property

About This Property

Welcome to 38-1 Buttonball Road, an exceptional contemporary home privately situated on over 5 acres with sweeping west-facing views of the Black Hall River and Horseneck Creek. Offering 4-5 bedrooms and 4 full baths, this thoughtfully designed residence combines modern living with timeless elegance. A dramatic foyer welcomes you into a sun-filled open floor plan featuring three levels of finished living space. Expansive windows capture spectacular water views from almost all rooms creating a seamless connection to the natural beauty beyond. The home's custom design is complemented by classic architectural details and high-end finishes throughout. Additional highlights include a detached 3-car garage with versatile loft space above, and the privacy and tranquility of a secluded setting. Whether entertaining guests or enjoying a peaceful evening overlooking the river, this remarkable property offers a truly special lifestyle. Osprey and nest included in the sale of the house. Whole house Kohler generator installed 5/21.

Property Details

38-1 Buttonball Road, Old Lyme Connecticut 06371 — Single Family For Sale listed at $2,400,000.

At a Glance

4

Bedrooms

4

Bathrooms

4,230

Sq Ft

5.36

Lot Size

--

Garage

1983

Year Built

The Details

Property TypeSingle Family For Sale
NeighborhoodNew London
Address38-1 Buttonball Road
MLS Number24180149
Year Built1983
Square Footage4,230
Lot Size5.36
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms4
Water SourcePrivate Well

Property Details

Other Details

Appliances IncludedGas Cooktop,Wall Oven,Microwave,Range Hood,Refrigerator,Subzero,Icemaker,Dishwasher,Disposal,Washer,Gas Dryer
ColorGRAY
Estimated Annual Heat Cost4000
Parcel Number1552606
Parking Total Spaces12
Radon Mitigation Air YNUUnknown
Radon Mitigation Water YNUUnknown
Virtual Showing YN1
ZoningRU 40

Financial

Assessed Value718563
Mil Rate Total16.23
Property Tax11662
Tax YearJuly 2025-June 2026

Property Features

Attic DescriptionWalk-In
Attic YN1
Basement DescriptionNone
Cooling SystemCentral Air,Split System
Driveway TypeCircular
Energy FeaturesGenerator
Exterior FeaturesBarn,Patio
Exterior SidingClapboard
Fireplaces Total2
Foundation TypeConcrete
Fuel Tank LocationIn Ground
Garage ParkingDetached Garage,Driveway,Unpaved
Garages Number3
Heat Fuel TypeElectric,Propane
Heat TypeBaseboard,Hot Water,Other
Home AutomationElectric Outlet(s),Security System
Hot Water DescriptionPropane,Domestic
Interior FeaturesAuto Garage Door Opener,Cable - Available,Humidifier,Open Floor Plan
Laundry Room InfoLower Level
Laundry Room LocationLOWER LEVEL OFF BACK ENTRY
Roof InformationOther

All Photos (37)

MARKET CONTEXTOld Lyme
Town Median+349% vs list
$535,000
Old Lyme, CT
Mill Rate
21.45
New London County
NYC Commute
140 min
Metro-North express
Schools
A-
1 graded
LOADING COMP CLOUD…

This listing is +349% vs the Old Lyme median. Verify against same-school-district comps before competing offers.

Contact Mim Beardsley

Fill out the form below and we will respond promptly.

Affordability Calculator

$2,400,000

Down Payment$480,000
Loan Amount$1,920,000
Principal & Interest$12,136/mo
Property Tax$2,400/mo
Insurance$100/mo
Est. Monthly$14,636/mo

Listing Agent

M

Mim Beardsley

Houlihan Lawrence WD

Quick Facts

StatusActive
TypeSingle Family For Sale
ClassProperty
MLS #24180149
Last Updated2026-06-15